1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON

Expired - Members Only
MLS#:Members Only
5 beds
2 baths
1500-2000 sqft
14.0 parking
Residential Freehold
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 2 Bath Home at 1909 Effingham Street Pelham ON listed at $3,999,000 (MLS# X11984955) - Main View
For Sale
⚠️ Listing ExpiredThis property listing is currently expired.

Similar Listings in North Pelham, Pelham

Explore all Just Listed Homes in Pelham
Added:Feb 24, 2025(569 days ago)
Updated:Jun 25, 2025(448 days ago)
Last Checked:16 minutes ago

Property Highlights

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Welcome to this remarkable 1 1/2 Storey farm located in the coveted neighborhood of North Pelham. Expertly crafted featuring premium aluminum siding construction, this residence presents an exceptional opportunity offered at $3,999,000 to acquire a beautiful home in a highly sought-after setting. Designed for both comfortable daily living and elegant entertaining, the layout maximizes natural light, functional flow, and lifestyle utility.

  • 5 Bedrooms and 2 Bathrooms
  • Generous living space spanning 1500-2000 sqft on a premium 1309.52 x 1524.9 ft lot
  • Features a partially finished, full basement, adding superb versatility for recreation, a home gym, or extra storage
  • 14.0 total parking spaces available with a convenient carport configuration
  • Notable attributes: Water Heater Owned, Primary Bedroom - Main Floor
  • Efficient forced air heating via gas

Description

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

A rare opportunity to own a 45.35-acre farm in the heart of Niagara's agricultural region. The farm has been family-owned and operated since 1952 and features a thriving pick-your-own fruit farm, cash crops, two homes, two barns, a fruit stand, a 100' deep spring well and a scenic pond. The 9-acre orchard produces sweet and sour cherries, apples, pears, mulberries, pawpaws, and raspberries, including a small patch of specialty raspberries imported from Italy and England. Pawpaws, a rare delicacy in the region, add uniqueness, while mulberries represent a growing market. Over 35 acres are planted with soybeans, providing additional income. The farm follows sustainable practices, including an integrated pest management system for cherries and chemical-free raspberries and blackberries. The property includes two residences. The main home is a 1562 sqft 1.5-storey farmhouse with five bedrooms and two bathrooms. A farm helper house features two self-contained units consisting of a one-bedroom unit and a three-bedroom unit, ideal for farm staff or multi-generational living. Outbuildings include a newly constructed 4,500-square-foot barn (2019) equipped with electricity and a heated workshop, as well as a historic barn that offers character and versatility. Additional structures include a fully operational fruit stand with a cooler, a pump house with an attached carport, and a scenic 0.25-acre pond, enhancing both irrigation and the farms natural beauty. Located just five minutes from Fonthill, this property provides easy access to grocery stores, restaurants, shopping, recreational facilities, golf courses, and excellent schools. Major highways are also nearby, offering the perfect balance of rural tranquility and modern convenience. This is a rare opportunity to own a historic, income-producing farm in one of Ontario's most desirable agricultural regions.

Contact Agent

Generate CMA Report

Property Summary

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

This farm located at 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham is currently for sale and has been available on SousaSells for 569 days. This property is listed at $3,999,000 with an estimated mortgage of $13,311* per month. It has 5 beds, 2 bathrooms, and is 1500-2000 square feet. 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham is in the North Pelham neighborhood.

* Estimated mortgage assumes a 30% down payment, 4.00% interest rate, and 30-year amortization.

Key Features

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
2
Kitchens
1
Living Area
1500-2000 sqft
Property Type
Residential Freehold

Additional Details

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

StatusExpired
Price$3,999,000
AddedFeb 24, 2025 (569 days ago)
UpdatedJun 25, 2025 (448 days ago)
Last Checked16 minutes ago
Transaction TypeFor Sale
List Office NameEXP REALTY

Property Details

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Property Sub-TypeFarm
Architectural Style1 1/2 Storey
ConstructionAluminum Siding
BasementPartially Finished, Full
Lot Size1309.52 × 1524.9 Acres
CountyNiagara
Annual Tax$6,029
Legal DescriptionPT LT 5 CON 5 PELHAM; PT RDAL BTN LT 4 & 5 CON 5 PELHAM (CLOSED BY UNREGISTERED BY-LAW) AS IN RO539425 (SECONDLY); PELHAM

Parking & Garage

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Parking Total14.0
Parking Space12
Garage TypeCarport

Heating & Cooling

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Heat SourceGas
Heat TypeForced Air
CoolingNone

Features

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Property Features

  • Tiled/Drainage
  • Lake/Pond

Interior Features

  • Water Heater Owned
  • Primary Bedroom - Main Floor

Security Features

None listed

Community Features

None listed

Property History

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

No historical data available for this property.

This could be the first listing for this address.

Pelham Homeowner & Seller AdvisoryOff-Market Reference

What is your house worth in Pelham?

This property at 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON has closed. If you own a home on this street or nearby in Pelham, recent market trends and verified sold prices directly determine your home equity.

Pelham Home Valuation

Curious how much your house is worth in Pelham? Get a free, data-backed comparative market evaluation.

Free Pelham Valuation

Pelham Listing Agent

Looking for the best realtor to sell your house in Pelham? Discover our 4K video marketing plan and proven sales track record.

Sell My House in Pelham

Why Isn't My House Selling?

Did your listing expire or sit on the market? Learn the 5 reasons homes don't sell in Pelham and how to relist for top dollar.

Relist Guide & Audit

Frequently Asked Questions about 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Q.What is the asking price for 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON ?

The current listing price for 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON in North Pelham, Pelham is $3,999,000.

Q.How many bedrooms and bathrooms does this property have?

This property features 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms across approximately 1500-2000 sqft.

Q.What property type and architectural style is 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON ?

1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON is a Farm (1 1/2 Storey) featuring a Partially Finished, Full basement.

Q.What key property features does 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON offer?

Key property features include: Tiled/Drainage, Lake/Pond.

Q.What interior features are included in this home?

Interior highlights include: Water Heater Owned, Primary Bedroom - Main Floor.

Q.Is parking available at this property?

Yes, this property offers parking space for 14.0 vehicles (Carport).

Q.What heating and cooling systems are installed?

Heating is provided via Gas and cooling via None.

Virtual Tour Locked

Virtual tour and 3D walkthroughs for this unavailable or expired listing are reserved for free members.

Virtual Tour & 3D Walkthrough

Virtual 360° Walkthrough & Live Video Tour

Request a live agent video tour or get 3D virtual walkthrough access for 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON .

Location

Initializing map...
1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON
Neighborhood Safety Index

Neighborhood Safety & Crime Analytics

North Pelham, Pelham

SAFETY RATING9.4 / 10
Low Incident Area
Total Annual Incidents35 incidents / yr
Average Per Month2.9 incidents / mo
Population BenchmarkArea Average residents
Personal Safety
Very Low

8 assaults (30.0/100k)

Property Security
Very Low

8 B&E (30.0/100k)

Auto Theft Risk
Low Risk

10 thefts (35.0/100k)

1-Year Trend
▼ 6%

Improving vs previous year

How Per-Capita Rate (Per 100,000 Residents) Is Calculated:

Formula: (Annual Occurrences / Population) × 100,000. This standard policing calculation normalizes incident frequencies across different population sizes, allowing accurate safety comparisons between quiet residential pockets and dense urban centres.

Source: Official Police Services ArcGIS Open Data
Halton & GTA Police Network

Disclaimer: Crime and safety analytics are compiled from official municipal and regional police open data records for general consumer informational and demographic research purposes only. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and does not constitute a legal representation or guarantee of future safety.

Pricing & Value Insights

Data-driven valuation for 1909 Effingham Street, Pelham, ON L0S 1M0

Unlock sold price, full history & more

Real estate boards require a verified account to access this data — free and fast to join

Estimated Sales Range
$1.2M - $1.4M

Based on 0 recent similar sales in the pocket.

Market Speed
Loading stats...

Properties in this area are selling at a steady pace.

Market Trend
Calculating trend...

North Pelham, Pelham Neighborhood Guide

Comprehensive city-wide demographics, local real estate stats, and school rankings for North Pelham, Pelham.

Verified Local Data
City Population2,794,356
City Median Age39.2 Yrs
City Ownership48% Owners
Avg Area List Price$2,581,830

People & Families

Age Distribution

Household Composition

One-person households
32%
Families with children
36%
Couples without children
24%
Other households
8%

Top Ethnic Origins

Chinese11%
English9%
Canadian8%
East Indian8%

Best Schools in North Pelham, Pelham

Elementary Schools

No elementary schools data loaded.

Secondary Schools

No secondary schools data loaded.

North Pelham, Pelham Demographic Home information

Structural Home Types

Tenure (Ownership vs Rental)

Owner-Occupied48%
Rented52%

Need more details or a custom CMA?

Generate a full market evaluation or explore city guides using the sidebar links.

Notice: Market Insights are generated by analyzing real-time data and should be used for informational purposes only. Consult with a licensed professional for exact valuations.

Disclaimer: AI Insights are generated by an automated system and should be used for informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy using current market data and deep-learning models, these assessments do not constitute professional real estate, legal, or financial advice. All property values, predictions, and scores are estimates. We strongly recommend verifying all property details and conducting independent due diligence with a licensed professional before making any purchase decisions.

Similar Active Listings in Pelham

Compare prices, square footage, and school zones for similar Residential Freehold nearby

All Pelham Homes
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 5 Bath Home at 398 Canboro Road Pelham ON listed at $3,498,000 (MLS# X13737488)
Added 7 days ago
$3,498,000
4bd
5ba
Residential Freehold

398 Canboro Road, Pelham

Sep 1, 2026
DOM: 16

No description available

MLS#: X13737488
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 4 Bed, 5 Bath Home at 2600 Maple Street Pelham ON listed at $2,999,900 (MLS# X12971408)
Unavailable
members only
Unavailable: Members Only
4bd
5ba
Residential Freehold

2600 Maple Street, Pelham

Apr 8, 2026
DOM: 162

Details & description blurred for terminated/expired listing.

MLS#: Members Only
Terminated
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 4 Bath Home at 2021 Victoria Avenue Pelham ON listed at $2,999,900 (MLS# X12952556)
$2,999,900
5bd
4ba
Residential Freehold

2021 Victoria Avenue, Pelham

Apr 2, 2026
DOM: 168

No description available

MLS#: X12952556
For Sale
Residential Freehold for sale - 5 Bed, 4 Bath Home at 2021 Victoria Avenue Pelham ON listed at $3,749,900 (MLS# X12599358)
Unavailable
members only
Unavailable: Members Only
5bd
4ba
Residential Freehold

2021 Victoria Avenue, Pelham

Dec 3, 2025
DOM: 288

Details & description blurred for terminated/expired listing.

MLS#: Members Only
Terminated